[This Kind of War A Study in Unpreparedness Read online] PDF By T.R. Fehrenbach – Book or DOC

Read This Kind of War A Study in Unpreparedness

Arfare that marked this bloody period of history one which has been all but forgotten Hailed as a must for all soldiers and former soldiers by an com reviewer THIS KIND OF WAR restores the Korean War to its rightful place in American history as a touchstone for United States foreign engagement and a lesson for politicians ready to shed American blood on far away soil?. Wish I knew all this soonerI knew very little about the Korean War I ve studied both World Wars Vietnam and the Cold War in general but Korea hardly ever comes up I never realized how strong an effect Korea had on American policy until now If you are interested in Foreign policy and the Cold War I highly recommend learning about this chapter in history if not from Fehrenbach then from somewhereThe writing itself is somewhat heavy on military details and will likely be difficult for someone unfamiliar with that sort of terminology Fehrenbach also occasionally gives grand descriptions to events and players with legions on the far frontier coming fairly often in various arrangements Having served in the military myself I can appreciate themes like this Given Fehrenbach s own service it is hardly surprising to see though I imagine others might have a lesser view of such things The greatest strength of the book is the ease with which Fehrenbach transitions from macro level strategic and political concerns written in an easy to follow manner to the micro level experiences of individual men who are used to illuminate the struggles faced by men in all areas of the war Having completed the book I can see the frustration of the men in the field unable to understand why Washington and the UN was tying their hands partway into the war I can see why the US and UN leaders were trying to hold back hoping to avoid a general war with the Soviets and I think I understand a little bit better what the Communists were trying to do in Korea though I despise their leaders actions Personally I reacted with a bit emotion to this book than I expected The events of the Korean War seem like some sort of tragic pointless fiction rather than reality I can understand why no one wants to dwell on it But I think it is history that bitter as it tastes should be better known I saw faint reflections of modern times reflected in this history of the Korean War and I think there are lessons in it which should not be tossed asideIn summary I give This Kind of War 4 stars It is an excellent book which is perhaps a bit heavy on military maneuvering I think some might get bogged down in these details but it is worth pressing through It is also far less dry than you might expect Note The Kindle edition is riddled with a huge number of typos to the point that I almost rated this three stars instead of four Some were so baffling that I had to come to a dead stop just to figure out what I was looking at It s still very readable as a whole but whoever is responsible for this version should be embarrassed The Illusionists up I never realized how strong an effect Korea had on American policy O Último Testamento (Maggie Costello, until now If you are interested in Foreign policy and the Cold War I highly recommend learning about this chapter in history if not from Fehrenbach then from somewhereThe writing itself is somewhat heavy on military details and will likely be difficult for someone One for My Baby unfamiliar with that sort of terminology Fehrenbach also occasionally gives grand descriptions to events and players with legions on the far frontier coming fairly often in various arrangements Having served in the military myself I can appreciate themes like this Given Fehrenbach s own service it is hardly surprising to see though I imagine others might have a lesser view of such things The greatest strength of the book is the ease with which Fehrenbach transitions from macro level strategic and political concerns written in an easy to follow manner to the micro level experiences of individual men who are Paragon Walk (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, used to illuminate the struggles faced by men in all areas of the war Having completed the book I can see the frustration of the men in the field We unable to The Moon Platoon (Space Runners, understand why Washington and the UN was tying their hands partway into the war I can see why the US and UN leaders were trying to hold back hoping to avoid a general war with the Soviets and I think I The Echo (The Anomaly Quartet, understand a little bit better what the Communists were trying to do in Korea though I despise their leaders actions Personally I reacted with a bit emotion to this book than I expected The events of the Korean War seem like some sort of tragic pointless fiction rather than reality I can The Asset (Wounded Warrior understand why no one wants to dwell on it But I think it is history that bitter as it tastes should be better known I saw faint reflections of modern times reflected in this history of the Korean War and I think there are lessons in it which should not be tossed asideIn summary I give This Kind of War 4 stars It is an excellent book which is perhaps a bit heavy on military maneuvering I think some might get bogged down in these details but it is worth pressing through It is also far less dry than you might expect Note The Kindle edition is riddled with a huge number of typos to the point that I almost rated this three stars instead of four Some were so baffling that I had to come to a dead stop just to figure out what I was looking at It s still very readable as a whole but whoever is responsible for this version should be embarrassed

review É PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB × T.R. Fehrenbach

This Kind of War A Study in Unpreparedness

Igate loss of American lives in Korea The author TR Fehrenbach an officer in the conflict provides us with accounts of the combat situation that could only have been written by an eyewitness in the thick of the action But what truly sets this book apart from other military memoirs is the piercing analysis of the global political maneuverings behind the brutal ground w. Great book about the Korean War I read this book because while in the Marines one of my commanding officers gave me an copy of chapter 25 entitled Proud Legions That chapter is still my favorite in the book because it talks about the valor and fighting ability of the Marine Corps compared to other fighting units The thing that I enjoyed the most about the book is that it taught me a lot about the Korean war I drew a lot of parallels between the war in Ira and the Korean war If you read this book look for the similarities they blew me away For example their was a horrible incident at a POW camp that altered the entire war Can you say Abu Ghraib

T.R. Fehrenbach × 6 Summary

THIS KIND OF WAR is the most comprehensive single volume history of the Korean American conflict that began in 1950 and is still affecting United States' foreign policy Fifty years later not only does this enlightening account give details of the tactics infantrymen and euipment but also chronicles the story of military and political unpreparedness that led to a profl. TR Fehrenbach s This Kind of War is of a US Army history of the Korean War It is long on tacticaloperational detail placing less stress on politics diplomacy and grand strategy surrounding the war Ferhenbach has an ax to grind but it is strictly professional He despairs over the state of the army at the start of the war unprepared under euipped and under trained then analyzes and chronicles how the force hardened after being bloodied The author accepts reality albeit with some complaint that political necessity forced the US to defend its interests far from home in wars that reuired far less than total national commitment Then he gripes at what a poor job the national command authority did selling this necessity to the American people Fehrenbach really takes aim at the Doolittle Commission of 1946 This body rearranged the relationship between the line soldier and his NCO and CO basically robbing commanders of their ability to enforce discipline The author devotes pages to this citing it as the principle cause for the army s softening in the inter war years I checked for citations about this body in three different books on US military history finding brief citation in only one From there the nitty gritty of endless company and battalion fights are recited in lengthy detail But Fehrenbach does not succumb to the dry explanations that often accompany the arrows drawn on maps often found in the writings of armchair generals Leadership plays a key role in winning the hard fight The author will stress this when units do well but does not lay blame as hard as Halberstam did in The Coldest War There were times when Halberstam was vehement about MacArthur Fehrenbach simply notes that he made mistakes but does not list them all There is also some generational distance that the reader may have a hard time grasping Fehrenbach decries how permissive American society had become in 1950 The young men who fought in Korea had personal experience in the Great Depression and certainly experienced rationing during WWII Like their parents they enjoyed some measure of peace and prosperity during the post WWII years Maybe permissive isn t the right word here as we associate permissive with Woodstock 1969 not Peoria 1949 The author again stresses the necessity for a professional army that trains realistically and accepts deployment battle and suffering without uestion while acknowledging the necessity for a citizen army in a democracy that may not be well motivated to fight a war for reasons of state as opposed to a total war for national survival I wish I read This Kind of War a decade ago Better late than never this one stays on my shelf The Forgotten Memoir of John Knox unpreparedness that led to a profl. TR Fehrenbach s This Kind of War is of a US Army history of the Korean War It is long on tacticaloperational detail placing less stress on politics diplomacy and grand strategy surrounding the war Ferhenbach has an ax to grind but it is strictly professional He despairs over the state of the army at the start of the war The Illusionists unprepared Planet of the Bugs under euipped and Fishes of the Open Ocean under trained then analyzes and chronicles how the force hardened after being bloodied The author accepts reality albeit with some complaint that political necessity forced the US to defend its interests far from home in wars that reuired far less than total national commitment Then he gripes at what a poor job the national command authority did selling this necessity to the American people Fehrenbach really takes aim at the Doolittle Commission of 1946 This body rearranged the relationship between the line soldier and his NCO and CO basically robbing commanders of their ability to enforce discipline The author devotes pages to this citing it as the principle cause for the army s softening in the inter war years I checked for citations about this body in three different books on US military history finding brief citation in only one From there the nitty gritty of endless company and battalion fights are recited in lengthy detail But Fehrenbach does not succumb to the dry explanations that often accompany the arrows drawn on maps often found in the writings of armchair generals Leadership plays a key role in winning the hard fight The author will stress this when Out of Bounds (Boundaries, units do well but does not lay blame as hard as Halberstam did in The Coldest War There were times when Halberstam was vehement about MacArthur Fehrenbach simply notes that he made mistakes but does not list them all There is also some generational distance that the reader may have a hard time grasping Fehrenbach decries how permissive American society had become in 1950 The young men who fought in Korea had personal experience in the Great Depression and certainly experienced rationing during WWII Like their parents they enjoyed some measure of peace and prosperity during the post WWII years Maybe permissive isn t the right word here as we associate permissive with Woodstock 1969 not Peoria 1949 The author again stresses the necessity for a professional army that trains realistically and accepts deployment battle and suffering without Grass, Sky, Song uestion while acknowledging the necessity for a citizen army in a democracy that may not be well motivated to fight a war for reasons of state as opposed to a total war for national survival I wish I read This Kind of War a decade ago Better late than never this one stays on my shelf


10 thoughts on “This Kind of War A Study in Unpreparedness

  1. says:

    TR Fehrenbach served in the Korean War as an officer in the US Army His experiences shaped this book This Kind Of War is an account

  2. says:

    As a former Army officer I have read many military history books; and I assert that This Kind of War is the best military history book I have ever read As a retired Army officer and Korean War veteran writing approximately

  3. says:

    TR Fehrenbach's This Kind of War is of a US Army history of the Korean War It is long on tacticaloperational detail placing less stress on politics diplomacy and grand strategy surrounding the war Ferhenbach has an ax to grind but it is strictly professional He despairs over the state of the army at the start of the war unprepared under eui

  4. says:

    TR Fehrenbach who died just two years ago was an American historian and journalist who served in the Korean War and published this history of that war in 1963 It is an interesting work that provides an historical overview of the conflict The 50th anniversary edition includes very helpful maps without which a reader unfamiliar with

  5. says:

    times change and so do our expectations and language there's some 1920s era world history free ebook floating around and although the work is completely readable the modern reader is somewhat shocked to see written without any sense of ironythe Negro should blame himself for his plight for nations must organize themselves firstas if of course Africans or African Americans are one person 'the Negro'TR Fehrenbach wrote his classic 1961 Korea

  6. says:

    Great book about the Korean War I read this book because while in the Marines one of my commanding officers gave me an copy of chapter 25 entitled Proud Legions That chapter is still my favorite in the book because it talks about the valor and fighting ability of the Marine Corps compared to other fighting units The thing that I enjoyed the most about the book is that it taught me a lot about the Korean war I drew a lot

  7. says:

    Wish I knew all this soonerI knew very little about the Korean War I've studied both World Wars Vietnam and the Cold War in general but Korea hardly ever comes up I never realized how strong an effect Korea had on American policy until now If you are interested in Foreign policy and the Cold War I highly recommend learning about this chapter in history if not from Fehrenbach then from somewhereThe writing itself is somewhat heavy

  8. says:

    Soap box Fehrenbach is a huge fan of General McArthur and is cutting him all kinds of slack for his decisions wh

  9. says:

    There's lots of sentimental bullshit about lions and legions and stoic defense of the frontiers and the necessity of harsh just professional men to do unspeakable things in the service of polite gentle folk which is unfortunate because on balance it's a good book This stuff is partially redeemed by truly incisive analysis

  10. says:

    I have machinated for a feed days on how I can write any review that does this book justice Written in 1963 this work is much than a discussion of the Korean War on a tactical or operational level On the eve of large scale US intervention in Vietnam the author delves into the problems faced by liberal societies in engaging in limite

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *